Luke's Lobster's lobster rolls always leave me speechless (took me a while to even construct this very sentence).
7th St. & 1st. Ave.
More locations in FiDi, UES, UWS, Brooklyn, etc.
The glorious lobster roll
But in the end, it's worth it. Every bite is amazing except for the last, which will leave you disappointed that you scarfed down the entire roll in .08 seconds.